AusLeisure

Hills Shire Council in western Sydney has approved a $55.5 million redevelopment of its ageing Waves Aquatic Centre - a project first budgeted at costing between $19 and $23 million.

On Tuesday night, Councillors voted to support the multimillion-dollar redevelopment of the 52-year-old Baulkham Hills facility that will include upgraded pools with hydrotherapy and learn-to-swim indoor facilities and an expansive fitness centre.

Councillors also approving a masterplan for the future inclusion of a children’s water play area and additional 10-lane 25 metre outdoor pool.

Hills Shire Mayor Michelle Byrne told the Hills Shire Times “we have chosen an option that strikes a balance between recreational swimming and play, fitness, rehabilitation and squad training.

“It also provides indoor and outdoor recreational uses, as well as providing additional carparking and greatly improved gym space.

“Council will now prepare a detailed design for a construction tender, with construction to commence in the first half of 2020.”

Deputy Mayor, Alan Haselden justified the development based on population growth of the area, adding “as higher density living increases across The Hills over the next 20 years, there will be more and more families without a backyard - so all of these things point in the direction of a liveable, quality aquatic facility for the future of The Hills.”

However, Councillor Elizabeth Russo said she was left “disgusted and speechless by extreme blowout of costs”.

She told the Hills Shire Times “previous construction costs given to councillors just last month suggested the redevelopment would cost between $19 and $23 million.

“This is more than double our expectation and I don’t know where it all went wrong.

Councillor Mike Thomas said he was never shown any designs that “meet the brief of the budget” and stated “we are looking at more than double the cost of Hornsby’s Aquatic Centre.

“No one is opposed to upgrading the pool but we have to do it in a responsible way and this project appeared to be well managed until a month ago when the cost was blown out by two to three times the cost of other councils.”

In response to this, a spokesperson for project architect NBRS Architecture was quoted by the Hills Shire Times that pools are “finite features and their costs are also finite”, adding “we answered the brief required of us.

“It was clear it would require a greater budget and we have provided what the councillors asked for and done this as economically as possible.”

Reference to the NBRS Architecture website appears to show that the practice has designed just a single aquatic facility, the Ruth Everuss Aquatic Centre in Auburn, but do have a large portfolio of designs for residential, retail and church projects.

Australasian Leisure Management has previously questioned the high cost of aquatic facility developments and a budget of $55.5 million for the refurbishment of an outdoor 50 metre pool and the addition of an indoor learn-to-swim indoor pool and gym would appear to be a further example of this.

Australasian Leisure Management Publisher, Nigel Benton stated “this would appear to be a massive cost for the construction of a couple of pools and a gym.

“Certainly, the design is impressive but aquatic, fitness and recreation facilities in the majority of locations need to be functional and low-cost and not to be bespoke structures that are designed to secure architectural awards.

“It is good to see that the concept designs for this facility include a large array of solar-panelling - a feature often ignored in extravagant roof designs that, over the past decade or so, have all-too-often featured skylights, wave shapes and other bon-functional elements.

“However, the industry has to move towards more modular ‘off-the-shelf’ designs for facilities that are proven to be cost effective and efficient to build, operate and maintain and not fuel the egos of architects who seek to build monuments.”

The report considered by Councillors included four different options for the future of the facility, which opened in 1967, including a $12.6 million basic upgrade to the pool, a $39.6 million like-for-like redevelopment of the centre featuring an indoor leisure pool, the - now accepted - $55.5 million expansion with additional splash pad and warm water rehabilitation pool, gym and group fitness centre and an ambitious $63.3 million expansion adding another 23 metre learn-to-swim and leisure pool and a series of water slides.

The report said the catchment area for Waves Aquatic Centre is capable of delivering the numbers to support a $63.3 million redevelopment, advising “with this option there are concerns that the intensity would impact on community negatively given that the neighbouring community is of a predominate low density, single lot housing character and scale.

“Best practice would suggest that the facility would need to be designed to maximise operating hours, maximise activity, minimise circulation space for efficiency and sustain a universal mix of uses that have compatibility.”

Other examples of massive cost blowouts of aquatic facilities include the Ashfield Aquatic Centre - where costs have risen from $14 million to $42 million for an impressive wave-shaped roof facility and the City of Sydney's Gunyama Park Aquatic and Recreation Centre where costs have risen from a 2015 estimate of $50 million to a currently advised $84 million.

Australasian Leisure Management understands that the likely final cost of the Gunyama Park facility is set to exceed $100 million.

Click here for more information on the project.

Images: Architects' concepts for the Waves Aquatic Centre, courtesy of Hills Shire Council. The middle image shows elements of the $63.3 million redevelopment.

Related Articles

8th June 2019 - Recreation Aotearoa releases aquatic facility design guide

21st May 2019 - Gunyama Park Aquatic and Recreation Centre budget rises to almost $85 million

25th March 2019 - Inner West Council secures funding for redevelopment of aquatic facilities

17th September 2018 - City of Canning sues firms over green claims for Cannington Leisureplex

22nd August 2018 - Baulkham Waves team member receives Royal Life Saving Excellence in Customer Service award

16th August 2018 - World’s best sports leisure buildings shortlisted among categories at World Architecture Festival Awards

9th April 2018 - City of Wodonga to undertake expensive tiling repairs at WAVES aquatic centre

23rd January 2018 - Landmark Sydney aquatic centre set to open in 2020

4th March 2017 - FINA and Myrtha combine to launch global ‘Pools for All’ initiative

15th July 2016 - Green Square aquatic centre architects set ambitious sustainability target

8th July 2016 - Australian pools get international architectural recognition

1st July 2016 - Landmark Sydney aquatic centre to benefit from low-carbon energy

8th October 2015 - Victoria reveals new approach to infrastructure and design

24th September 2015 - Universal design to be explored as part of ACAA Conference

2nd September 2015 - Architects highlight contemporary aquatic and recreation facilities as social hubs

12th August 2015 - Sydney’s costly affair with extravagant aquatic centres

4th November 2014 - Winning Green Square Aquatic Centre design brings a beach to central Sydney

20th November 2013 - New Moss Vale War Memorial Aquatic Centre saves millions by using new procurement model

---

Support our industry news service
We hope that you value the news that we publish so while you're here can we ask for your support?

As an independent publisher, we need reader support for our industry news gathering so ask that - if you don't already do so - you back us by subscribing to the printed Australasian Leisure Management magazine and/or our online news.